Encore Theatre
A Non-Professional Theatre Owned and Operated by
Amil Tellers of Dramatics Inc
Lima Ohio USA
Welcome to our Website
2025-2026 Season
Five Adult Productions & Three Youth Productions
Check back often. More information to follow.
February 27-March 1 & March 6-8, 2026
Friday & Saturday performances @ 8pm, Sunday performances @ 2pm
A romantic comedy/drama by Sean Grennan
One night in 1981, just as Jamie is closing the bar where he works, a desperate last-minute customer offers him and his girlfriend Abby two thousand dollars to sit and have a drink with him. As the trio swaps stories, Jamie considers the decisions he faces about his musical career and his future with Abby. The young couple begins to realize that this older man is unusually invested in their choices... and the reason he gives them is completely unbelievable. But when a very displeased second stranger arrives, the unbelievable begins to look like it just might be true. Now and Then is a heartfelt romantic comedy about the costs of the the choices we make, and the people who make them with us.
Tickets for Now and Then will be available to the general public on Monday, February 9, 2026 at 1:00pm online (for a fee), at 419-223-8866 (leave your name, number and ticket request and a volunteer will get back to you as soon as possible) or at the Box Office (see new hours below). Season Ticket holders: You will need the email address we have on file for the season pass holder and the passcode from your season ticket receipt to book your own seats.
Box Office hours TBA.
Show Tickets
Adult $16.00
Senior (62+) $13.00
Student $10.00*
Youth $8.00 (10 & Under)
*Including College with ID
2025-2026 Ticket Prices
Individual Adult Show Tickets:
Adult—$16 Senior—$13 (62+) Student—$10*
Youth—$8 (10 & Under)
Holiday Show & Musicals:
Adult—$18 Senior—$15 (62+) Student—$12*
Youth—$10 (10 & Under)
*Including College with ID
Youth Theatre:
Individual tickets only
Ages 10 & Under $5
All Others $10—No Discounts Apply
Ohio Community Theatre Association